9 Best Coffee Syrups for a Flavorful Brew
Updated: Aug. 05, 2024
Whip up barista-level drinks at home with the best coffee syrups, including gluten-free and sugar-free selections.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.Learn more.
If you’re an avid coffee drinker, chances are that one of the main reasons you visit your local coffee shop are all of the delicious flavors of coffee they have to offer. Going out for coffee can get expensive, but enjoying flavorful coffee drinks doesn’t to be. Making barista-style drinks at home is as easy as bringing home your favorite flavors of coffee syrup. Whether you recreate drinks you already know and love or invent your own, these coffee syrups will level up your at-home coffee game.
Starbucks Variety Pack
That daily Iced Brown Sugar Oat Milk Shaken Espresso can get really expensive, really fast. Skip the drive-thru and save money with these Starbucks coffee syrups. The variety pack includes classic vanilla, caramel and hazelnut—just what you need to make these copycat Starbucks drinks at home.
Sugar-Free Vanilla Syrup
Picture this: You’re looking for a way to make a healthier cup of coffee that doesn’t have quite so much sugar or calories. Along with these top-rated healthy coffee creamers, consider Jordan’s Skinny Syrups. One of the brand’s most popular flavors is sugar-free vanilla, which has zero calories, zero carbs and zero sugar.
Mocha Syrup
Chocolate lovers need this mocha coffee syrup in their lives (and their pantries). Not only is it vegan and free of artificial sweeteners, it comes with a convenient pump for easy dispensing. Psst! Use whatever’s left over for one of these mouthwatering mocha dessert recipes.
Salted Caramel Syrup
Torani is one of the best-known coffee syrup brands thanks to its quality taste and lack of high-fructose corn syrup. Although it has a ton of indulgent flavors, including French vanilla and chocolate Milano, one of its customer-favorites is salted caramel. The perfect combo of sweet and salty, it’s just what you need for that homemade iced caramel cappuccino.
Coconut Syrup
Give your coffee an island-inspired twist with this coconut syrup. Made with all-natural ingredients, including fresh coconut and pure cane sugar, it makes you feel like you’re sipping your java in Hawaii.
Pumpkin Pie Syrup
If you spend all year dreaming of pumpkin spice lattes, start making your own at home with this pumpkin pie coffee syrup. Dairy- and gluten-free, it has hints of buttery crust, pumpkin, cinnamon and nutmeg. We bet it would pair perfectly with one of our best pumpkin recipes of all time.
Rose Syrup
Rose? In coffee? It’s more mainstream than you might think. With this organic rose syrup, you can brew up an Instagram-worthy floral latte. Bonus: For every bottle you purchase, the company gives a meal to a child in need via the GiveLight Foundation.
Sugar-Free Sweetening Syrup
For sweetness without the flavor—or the calories—look no further than this sugar-free syrup, which is a great alternative to Splenda or other artificial sweetener packets. Just mix a few drops into your mug, along with a dash of our experts’ favorite coffee creamers, for a delicious morning brew.
Irish Cream Syrup
Not up for a boozy coffee at 8 a.m. on a Monday morning? Fair enough. Fortunately, there are non-alcoholic ways to enjoy your favorite Irish cream. Take this preservative-free coffee syrup, for instance. It has the creamy vanilla and chocolate flavors you love—minus the alcohol.
What to Consider When Shopping for Coffee Syrup Flavors
Coffee syrups are a fun and delicious way to change your coffee routine. They add a little bit of flavor and sweetness all at once. When shopping for coffee syrup, the three most important factors to consider are flavor, ingredients and price.
Coffee syrups come in a wide range of flavors, from standard coffee shop fare like vanilla and caramel to fruity flavors like blueberry and everything in between. Consider what flavors you most enjoy and which will complement your preferred coffee. For example, some flavors, like vanilla, are more subtle than others, like mocha or caramel.
Consider coffee syrup’s ingredients and seek options that use high-quality ingredients. Look for syrups that use natural flavors and sweeteners, prioritizing them over those that use artificial additives and poor-quality sweeteners like high-fructose corn syrup.
Pay attention to the price and weigh it against the quality of the ingredients and the flavor. High-quality syrups are usually more expensive but may be worth it if you prefer the taste. Budget-friendly options can be tasty, but make sure the ingredients are ones you can trust.
Why You Should Trust Us
Amanda Tarlton, the author of this piece, has more than a decade of experience testing and reviewing products in the cooking and lifestyle space. She’s contributed to publications including Taste of Home and Field & Stream, focusing on foodie finds, home and lifestyle goods.
Nina Derwin is a commerce updates editor for Taste of Home. She has experience researching and reviewing various items to help shoppers find the best products on the market. She researched and updated this piece.
How We Found the Best Coffee Syrup Flavors
In searching for the best coffee syrup flavors, we considered a wide assortment of options, from classic vanilla to obscure flavors like rose and lavender. We began by looking for those that are the most versatile and can be used across all different types of drinks. Then, we factored in the intensity of the flavor, careful to include both subtle and robust options. Ultimately, we found that the best coffee syrup flavors are the ones you most enjoy!
Originally Published: April 12, 2023
